This research examines the interface between the financial Public Relations industry (PR) and journalists in South Africa and its implications for the production of content.
RESEARCH QUESTION
How is the production and framing of financial news shaped by the interaction between financial PR and journalists in South Africa?
SUB-QUESTIONSThe focus question - statedabove - can be broken down into the following sub-questions:
What is news framing and how does it relate to financial journalism, where news framing is defined as presenting news in a manner that serves a particular interest group
How do journalists on the one hand and PRs on the other define their roles?
What can we learn about the relative resources and skills of the two that clearly affects news framing?
What are the stated or implicit professional goals of financial journalists in South Africa, and how are these shaped by, for example, social controls in the newsroom?
What are the stated or implied professional goals of corporate communicators and how are these shaped by company policies or established values and routines?
ABSTRACT
The extent to which financial PR and journalists collaborate in the production of news is important given the fact that authorative financial news has become a priority in the public sphere after the global meltdown of 2008-2009. Financial news is now high on the public agenda.
Structural factors rather than any deliberate conspiracy are most likely to explain the form that financial news coverage takes. Journalists and PRs are both gatekeepers in their own ways, their actions being shaped by personal, professional, institutional and social pressures, which translate into professional ethics and modes of behaviour. On both sides there are explicit and implicit agendas for financial news coverage. This research project examines these agendas by asking both journalists and PRs what they do in relation to each other, how they do it,why they do it and whether transformation in South African society is having its impact on the relationship between enterprises and the media.
INTRODUCTION
In South Africa both PRs and journalists acknowledge the tensions that exist, but admit their mutual dependency. How this relationship is interpreted by both sides, becomes a question of attitude. Particularly in times of crisis, when the news is hot to handle, these attitudes have shaped the way PRs and reporters have dealt with each other. Although, in effect, PRs and journalists collaborate to frame the news, the relationship has never been uncomplicated.
It is no longer possible (if it ever were) to regard the exchange of information between PRs and journalists as merely a two-way trade, as many more voices, pressures and influences are coming into the picture. The overall effect is to make enterprises more accountable and hold them to higher standards of performance.