Ecstasy and Club Drugs

Ecstasy

IT'S NO ACCIDENT that MDMA's street name is "Ecstasy." Users of the drug report feelings of bliss, connection, and peace. They find that their relationships -- with other people, with the world -- are radically enhanced. Best of all, MDMA lacks the out-of-control feeling of LSD and other psychedelics, which is why many users have jumped to the conclusion that it is relatively safe. Yet growing evidence suggests that MDMA isn't quite a "soft" drug. Scientists have now confirmed that MDMA damages brain cells. Dozens of deaths by over-heating, heart problems, and unexpected overdoses have been reported. Even seemingly responsible measures to prevent overheating have themselves proven fatal. And just last month, researchers found that women who took MDMA during pregnancy had a birth-defect rate five times higher than normal. What's worse, years of careless drug-war politics have trained our ears to screen out claims of danger -- and it's preventing this information from reaching those who need it.

Politicians love to exaggerate drug risk, and when people get high and don't experience the horrors predicted, they discount negative information as mere propaganda. Even those who should know better -- people working to help drug users protect themselves from harm -- can be misled. Rather than considering that MDMA may not be safe, many harm reductionists have instinctively tried to debunk the research or tar scientists as government apologists. "People care very deeply about this drug and they know an enormous number of people who have taken it without problems." says Dr. John Morgan, a professor of pharmacology at CUNY medical school, "[Advocates] want to see researchers who did these studies as schlemiels or schnooks, but at this point there really is not much criticism possible [of the human neurotoxicity data]... the time to worry is now." So what do the data show? This means that the minority of users who do have the liver problem have more risk of overdose but less risk of brain damage, while the majority with normal livers are less likely to OD but more likely to harm their brains -- a "lose-lose" situation, for sure.

Still, skeptics will want to know why we haven't seen more problems, if MDMA is in fact killing brain cells in millions of people who take it regularly. Dr. Una McCann, a leading MDMA researcher at Johns Hopkins University Medical School offers one explanation: In cases of Parkinson's Disease, 80% of dopamine neurons must die before victims of the movement disorder experience symptoms -- and the same could be true here. Symptoms might not be seen until people have taken large quantities of MDMA, or until they lose additional neurons to aging. Negative MDMA effects might also be misattributed: Serotonin damage might result in low mood and high anxiety, which could be misdiagnosed as stress. Granted, there aren't good data on the prevalence of depression and other psychiatric problems in heavy MDMA users, but lower than normal levels of a serotonin byproduct are found in both those who attempt ...